Opinions Needed

I’m in a conundrum and could really use your help!

The other day I saw some really cool Facebook and Twitter icons and thought “Oh wow, those are cool! I should add those to my blog!”

Of course, I couldn’t leave it at that – oh no, that would be too easy. I always needs to explore all the options before making a decision, which drives Teacher crazy.

Even worse, I sometimes often have a hard time making a decision, which drives Teacher absolutely bonkers. You should see me at a restaurant trying to decide what to order. I usually end up getting a combo plate because I couldn’t decide. On second thought, no-one should be subjected to my level of indecisiveness.

So, instead of taking the easy also smart and logical route, and going with the first set of icons I liked I decided to see what else was out there. Of course there were a ton and now I can’t decide which go best with the current blog design.

You’re very smart and have extremely good taste so I’m asking for your help. Post below or through my contact page to vote for the icon set that YOU think goes best with MHCL. If you help me make this decision I will be forever grateful – and so will Teacher because he won’t have to listen to me change my mind a gazillion times!

The icons I’d most likely be using are Facebook, Twitter, Flickr, StumbleUpon, and maybe the RSS one, so those are the ones to base your decision on.

Here are the contenders, in no particular order:


Page Peel Social Media Icons - Gopal Raju1. Page Peel by Productive Dreams. These are the cool icons that started this whole ball rolling. I love the 3D look, but is it right for MHCL? That’s what I can’t decide.


Social Media Icons - Plechi2. Social Network Icons from IconExpo. These have a colored pencil look which appeals to my inner child. And my outer child – I may look like a grown-up but I don’t always act like one!


Social Media Icons - Plechi3. More Social Network Icons from IconExpo. These are also by Icon Expo but look like they were drawn with pen instead of colored pencil.


Social Media Icons - Noop4. Hand-Drawn Social Media Icons by Noop.NL. What can I say, I love the hand-drawn look! I’m not thrilled with the Twitter bird, but that could just be my bird phobia. That’s a story for another day, but I have to say it’s all Hitchcock’s fault.


Social Media Icons - Plechi5. Social Media Icons by plechi. Another hand-drawn look with bright colors. Note: If you vote for these please also vote for the upper or lower set. Decisions, decisions, decisions… see why I need your help?


Social Media Icons - White Magic6. White Magic by Cheth Studios. These will obviously fit right in with the white theme, but I’m not sure they’ve got the right feel… what do you think?

So there you have it, six choices to choose from. Which do YOU fits MHCL and why? Let me know what you’re thinking, and help me make this decision – please?

I can’t wait to hear what you think!

Amy Sue


  1. I like the white ones and the colored-in ones.

  2. Your link to my icon set at NOOP.NL is wrong. It points to the wrong site.

    It should be this:

    • Oops, sorry Jurgen! I’ve fixed it now. That’s what I get for trying to write with a 3 yr old’s “help.” (Check twice, paste once, check twice, paste once…)

      Thanks for letting me know!
      ~Amy Sue

  3. I’m going with No. 4 because I think they go best with your banner. But also like both “colored in” sets… Deffinately not number 1. Does that help?!

  4. I like the bottom set of #5.

    • Thanks Karen!

      I really liked those too. It’s interesting to see which ones people are voting for and which ones aren’t – not what I expected, that’s for sure.

      ~Amy Sue

  5. I like #4 or the pen colored in ones.

    • Thanks Karen!

      I like them all, which makes it really hard to decide. I’m always amazed by how many talented people are “out there” and how freely they share their talent.

      ~Amy Sue

Leave a Reply to Amy Sue Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.